First off, let me say this: there is no better place to see a show in New York City than Maxwell’s in Hoboken. (let that sink in, but it makes sense). And there’s no better place, at least for a hyper-fan like me, than standing front row in this small venue.
This was the second of eight charity shows Yo La Tengo were doing @ Maxwell’s, and each night the band had a rotating line-up of openers, stand in musicians, and special guests. My show opened with The Other Dimensions in Music, an experimental jazz band that played instruments and created sounds that I’ve never heard before.
The second act of the night was comedian Todd Barry. Let me tell you something. You might think a comedian at a rock show in a rock club might not make sense, but it absolutely does. It might suck with someone like The Amazing Jonathan, but with Barry, it was a perfect fit. He has a really great understanding of music (he name checked Tragically Hip!), and his humor worked well with the crowd.
It was finally time for hometown heroes Yo La Tengo to hit the stage, and they once again tore up Hoboken, deconstructing their catalog and recreating original songs like you’ve never heard them before. Other Dimensions joined them for the main set, improvising along to the band. When it didn’t work, it was bad, but when it worked, god, it was a thing of beauty. Luckily it worked more than it didn’t, and the band pulled off great versions of “Autumn Sweater,” “Nuclear War,” and an amazing cover of “Venus in Furs,” among others.
It takes a lot of guts for a band to invite an improvising jazz band to play with them and basically say “make it up as you go.” Easier said than done, right? Luckily, with a band as strong as Yo La Tengo, this experiment proved to be a success.
During the encore, Todd Barry came back and played drums on a Dylan song, and “Hedwig and the Angry Inch” star John Cameron Mitchell made a surprise appearance, performing Lou Reed and Neil Diamond songs.
A good, holy night of rock. On a side note, the band gave away free 3-song Christmas CDs to the crowd, and only charged ten dollars for t-shirts. Happy Christmas, indeed!